Sullivan Insurance Agency Logo
Google Plus Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Yelp* Blog RSS Feed
Get a Quote
Call Us: 800-456-9169
Car Insurance
Home Insurance
Agribusiness Insurance
Indian and Tribal
Login to HR Library
Username:
Password:
Forgot Password:

Succeed Risk Management


Quote Center

First Name Last Name
Email:
Phone:
Zip:
Interest:

Sullivan Insurance Agency
321 West Broadway
Ardmore, OK 73401
Get Map
Oklahoma City,
Phone: 580-223-2187
Fax: 580-223-1831
Toll Free: 800-456-9169
Email Us

Trusted Choice

About Us

About our Insurance Services

Founded in 1946 by Jack and Ruth Sullivan, the Sullivan Insurance Agency serves southern Oklahoma and the majority of the US as a family-owned independent insurance agency based in Ardmore, Oklahoma.

Their son, John F. Sullivan, Jr., continues his family’s legacy since purchasing the agency in 1974. John’s wife, Stacy, began working for the agency in 1991, bringing over her previous years of insurance experience and expertise. His daughter, Lena Treanor, joined the agency in 2003, becoming the third generation to proudly join the family's business. In 2007, Justin Arledge, Stacy’s son, became a part of the Sullivan Insurance family. 

Sullivan Insurance continues to grow; along with our office in Ardmore, we also have branch offices in Oklahoma City which has been open since 1993.

The Agency provides all types of insurance, from personal needs, like life, health, homeowners, auto, and ATV, boat, motorcycle, camper/RV, and pretty much anything else you might need.

Our primary concentration is in commercial lines, with specialty programs for Native American Tribes and Enterprises, as well as the agribusiness, manufacturing, distribution, contractors and religious institutions/church business models.

Our agency is an independent insurance agency - we represent many different insurance companies so we can find the one that is right for you. This allows us to compare rates and policies for you instead of you having to call around.

Our goal is to provide you with the insurance you want and need at the lowest possible price, while providing you with the highest level of customer service. We can furnish you with an assessment of your insurance needs and a choice of which package fits you best.

It helps to find an agency that you know and can trust. Our staff has the knowledge and experience with various insurance products to provide maximum benefit and protection to our clients. 
With our sound insurance practices, qualified staff members and emphasis on our staff's continuing education, we are confident we can serve you and your business.

We serve businesses across all of the United States, but focus in Oklahoma from Oklahoma City to Tulsa to Lawton as well as Texas areas like Dallas, Ft. Worth, Austin, Houston, San Antonio, Midland and everywhere in between. We also serve businesses in Kansas, Arkansas, Arizona, California, Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Louisiana, Missouri, Nebraska, North Carolina, Tennessee and Wyoming.


Main Location (Map)
John F. Sullivan, Jr. - CPCU, CICJohn F. Sullivan, Jr. - CPCU, CIC - Owner / Agency Primary - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

John F. Sullivan, Jr. graduated from Westminster College in 1970 with a Bachelors in Economics. In 1972 he received his MBA from Oklahoma City University. From 1971 to 1973 he was a Commercial Casualty Underwriter with the Insurance Company of North America. In 1976 he received his CPCU Designation. In 1981 he received his Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation. John also served on the Board of Directors of Associated Risk Managers of Mid-America, Inc., and served on the Associates Risk Managers International Board from 1989 to 1999 and 2011 to present.
Lena Treanor - CIC, CRMLena Treanor - CIC, CRM - Owner / Account Executive - Commercial, Hospitality, Non-Profit, Large & Small Commercial - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Lena is an Account Executive and co-owner of Sullivan Insurance Agency. She holds a Bachelor of Science from the University of Kansas in Biology. She is also a graduate of the Hartford School of Insurance in Hartford, Conn. She is licensed in Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas. Lena also holds the Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation. She currently serves on the Board of Directors for Ardmore Day Nursery, and is a past Board of Director for Ardmore Beautification Council and Broadway House.
Stacy A. Sullivan - CIC, ASCRStacy A. Sullivan - CIC, ASCR - Tribal and Large Commercial Account Executive - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Stacy Sullivan is involved in all aspects of business operations, insurance management and sales. She specializes in commercial insurance with a focus on tribal governments, casinos and other tribal enterprises - focusing on tribal programs offering property/casualty insurance and employee benefits.

She started her career in insurance in 1984, learning the basics of insurance as a customer representative handling large oil & gas customers.

In addition to being licensed in Oklahoma, Texas, Kansas, North Carolina, and Tennessee, she has completed her Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) and Accredited Customer Service Representative (ACSR) designations. She is a member of the Oklahoma Safety Council, which allows her to assist clients by reducing exposures and providing a safer working environment.
Justin Arledge - CICJustin Arledge - CIC - Commercial Account Executive - Tribal and Commercial - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Justin Arledge is an Account Executive in the Ardmore office specializing in Tribal Governments, Agribusiness, and Artisan Contractors. Justin is currently Vice President of the American Indian Chamber of Commerce of Oklahoma City. Accomplishments achieved include graduating from Westminster College in Fulton, MO where he earned his degree in Business Finance. Most recently he graduated from the Future Insurance Leaders of Oklahoma program and is currently in the inaugural class Leadership Native Oklahoma.

Justin is also a graduate of the Hartford School of Insurance and is licensed in Property, Casualty and Life and Health. Justin has successfully completed his Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation.

Justin is currently enrolled at the University of Oklahoma where he is partaking in the Masters of Legal Studies program that specializes in Indigenous People’s Law. Justin and his two daughters are proud members of the Chickasaw Nation and are avid supporters of Native American Rights and Sovereignty.

Outside of work Justin enjoys spending time with his family at the park, on the golf course, hunting and fishing, and especially boating on Lake Murray in the summer time. Justin has played billiards from an early age of his life and recently won the Oklahoma State Scotch Doubles 8 ball championship.
Diane HayesDiane Hayes - Office Manager/Bookkeeper - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Diane Hayes is the Bookkeeper and Office Manager for Sullivan Insurance Agency. She has an Associates from Tarrant County College in Ft. Worth, Texas and has been working in bookkeeping/accounting for 15 years. While in Ft. Worth, she worked in the health insurance industry for 5 years. She joined the agency in mid-2014.
Candice Richardson - CIC, CISRCandice Richardson - CIC, CISR - Commercial Account Executive - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Specializing in transportation, oil & gas, food service and agribusiness, Candice Richardson works with a diverse and sophisticated client base and is dedicated to pursuing continuing education in order to better serve her customers. She has both her Property & Casualty and Life & Health licenses.

Candice has been in the insurance industry since 2008. She received her Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) designation in 2011, and her Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation in 2015. She also completed the Food Certified program in 2016.

She holds a Bachelor of Science in Botany from The University of Oklahoma. She also graduated from the Future Insurance Leaders of Oklahoma in November of 2016 and Greater Ardmore Leadership Program in May of 2016. She has attended Nationwide’s Producer School and currently serves on the Board of Directors for the Ardmore Young Professionals.

Outside of work, Candice loves spending time on Lake Murray, golfing and attending OU sporting events, especially the football games. She has two boys, Collin and Cooper, and her husband, Gabe, is a local CPA and currently enlisted in his 18th year with the United States Air Force Reserves.
Jennifer Fryar - CIC, CISRJennifer Fryar - CIC, CISR - Account Manager for Stacy Sullivan - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Jennifer Fryar serves our Tribal clients as well as some of our large commercial customers. She holds a Bachelors of Business Administration in General Business from Southeastern Oklahoma State University. Jennifer has been in the insurance industry since 2001 and is currently licensed in Oklahoma for Property and Casualty and Life and Health. She holds her Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) and Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designations.
Emily Noland - CIC, CISREmily Noland - CIC, CISR - Account Manager for John Sullivan - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Emily works primarily with Tribal Government and Enterprise, Agribusiness and Commercial Insurance. Emily joined the agency at the end of 2014 after a year with Farm Bureau. She obtained her Associates Degree from Murray State College as well as a Bachelors in Business Administration with a focus on marketing from East Central University. While at ECU, she received the Outstanding Student in Marketing award and is a member of Alpha Chi Honor Society.

She is licensed in Property and Casualty as well as Life and Health. Emily has obtained her CISR designation and is working toward her CIC designation. In 2016 Emily was awarded the NextGen 30 under 30 Award. The NextGen Under 30 program recognizes innovative, creative, and inspiring individuals who push boundaries, in various categories of endeavors. Emily has received the NextGen Under 30 Award in the category of Finance. In addition, award winners are selected based upon their contribution to and participation within their communities
Susan Lucas - CISRSusan Lucas - CISR - Account Manager for Lena Sullivan and Donna Nunley - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Susan Lucas serves as Account Manager for both Lena Sullivan and Donna Nunley. She has been with the agency since 2004. She is licensed in Oklahoma in Property and Casualty and Life and Health. She currently holds her Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) and is pursuing her Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation.
Katie Williams - CISRKatie Williams - CISR - Personal Lines Account Manager - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Katie Williams is a Personal Lines Account Manager with our agency. She is dedicated to helping customers find the right fit for their personal insurance needs. She joined the agency in 2012. She obtained her Associates Degree from Murray State College and recently obtained her Bachelors from Southeastern Oklahoma State University. She is licensed in Oklahoma in Property and Casualty as well as a Life and Health. Katie holds the CISR designation and is working towards her CIC designation.
Carley ClarkCarley Clark - Personal Lines Account Manager - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Carley Clark is a Personal Lines Account Manager. She is dedicated to helping customers find the right fit for their personal insurance needs. She is pursuing her Bachelor degree in Business Management from Murray State College. She is licensed in Oklahoma in Property and Casualty and is also pursuing her Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) designation. Carley prides herself in providing great customer service to our current customers and prospective clients. She joined our agency in 2015 with a background in professional property management.
Jenna Davila - CISRJenna Davila - CISR - Commercial Lines Account Manager - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Jenna joined the agency in 2015. She obtained her Bachelors in Business Administration with a focus on General Business from East Central University. She graduated with honors from ECU. She is licensed in Oklahoma in Property and Casualty as well as Life and Health. Currently Jenna holds her CISR designation and is currently pursing her Certified Insurance Counselor designation.
Ashley Bigler - CISRAshley Bigler - CISR - Commercial Lines Account Manager - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Ashley started her insurance career at Sullivan in 2016. She is a commercial lines account manager who is actively pursuing her Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) designation. Ashley is married and has one daughter. Her husband is a local High School Band Director. Some of her favorite memories are the band trips taken to Orlando, Florida where they visited Disney World. Outside of work she loves to read and watch Texas Rangers Baseball.
April GatherApril Gather - Commercial Lines Account Manager - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

April starter her insurance career with Sullivan Insurance in 2016. She is currently licensed in Life and Health license. She is working directly with Jennifer Fryar and Stacy Sullivan to learn the ins and outs of Life and Health Insurance. April graduated from East Central University with a major in Graphic Design. Believe it or not she has a life outside of work where she enjoys spending time with family, especially her niece who she spoils as if she were her own. April is quite the accomplished artist. Her works have been published at East Central University and her medium is water color. You can view her work at www.aprilgaitherartist.weebly.com
Micah Shelton - CISRMicah Shelton - CISR - Commercial Lines Account Manager - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Micah began her insurance career with Sullivan Insurance in 2016. She received her Bachelors in Business from Southeastern Oklahoma State University, where she graduated with honors. She is currently pursuing her Masters degree in Native American Studies and will be graduating in May of 2017. Micah recently became licensed in Property and Casualty as well as Life and Health and she also completed her CISR designation. Both Micah and her son, TJ, are proud members of the Choctaw Nation.
Yakoke!
Irina Smith - CISRIrina Smith - CISR - Office Receptionist - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-223-2187)

Irina assists where needed in each department of our office, specifically in Tribal Claims. She has recently obtained her Oklahoma Property and Casualty as well as Life and Health license. She is also actively pursuing her CIC designation. Outside of work, Irina enjoys spending time with her kids and going to the gym in her spare time.
Oklahoma City (Map)
Stacy Washburn- CRM, CICStacy Washburn- CRM, CIC - Commercial Account Executive - Manufacturing, Distribution, Contractors - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 580-380-2350)

Stacy Washburn is an Account Executive in Oklahoma City, who previously managed our Durant, Oklahoma, office. She is a business owner as well as an Executive for our agency. Stacy is currently licensed in Oklahoma, Texas, Louisiana, New Mexico, and Alabama. She holds both the Certified Risk Manager (CRM) and Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designations. Her background includes ten years as a direct writer, and twenty as an independent agent. Stacy specializes in the programming, placement and servicing of large commercial accounts, such as manufacturers, distributors, fabricators, auto and RV dealers, petroleum distributors, equipment dealers and contractors. She is a member of the Oklahoma City Chamber of Commerce and the National Association of Professional Women.
Donna NunleyDonna Nunley - Commercial Account Executive - (Direct: 800-456-9169 - 405-748-5700)

Donna Nunley is an Account Executive in our Edmond/Oklahoma City office. She has 30 years experience in all aspects of commercial business insurance specializing in the construction and manufacturing industry. Her background includes 5 years of commercial business insurance rating, providing her a competitive edge. She holds an Alliance of American Insurance Certificate, R&R Newkirk Business Insurance Certification, and an Oklahoma State Property & Casualty, Surety and Life and Health license.
(Map)
Located in Ardmore, OK ; Oklahoma City, OK and , . We also serve the Austin, TX, Dallas/Ft. Worth, TX, Houston, TX, Oklahoma City, Ok and San Antonio, TX areas. - Licensed in Arkansas, Arizona, California, Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Kansas, Louisiana, Missouri, North Carolina, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas and Wyoming